• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

Electrical Engineering News and Products

Electronics Engineering Resources, Articles, Forums, Tear Down Videos and Technical Electronics How-To's

  • Products / Components
    • Analog ICs
    • Battery Power
    • Connectors
    • Microcontrollers
    • Power Electronics
    • Sensors
    • Test and Measurement
    • Wire / Cable
  • Applications
    • 5G
    • Automotive/Transportation
    • EV Engineering
    • Industrial
    • IoT
    • Medical
    • Telecommunications
    • Wearables
    • Wireless
  • Learn
    • eBooks / Handbooks
    • EE Training Days
    • Tutorials
    • Learning Center
    • Tech Toolboxes
    • Webinars & Digital Events
  • Resources
    • White Papers
    • Educational Assets
    • Design Guide Library
    • Digital Issues
    • Engineering Diversity & Inclusion
    • LEAP Awards
    • Podcasts
    • DesignFast
  • Videos
    • EE Videos and Interviews
    • Teardown Videos
  • EE Forums
    • EDABoard.com
    • Electro-Tech-Online.com
  • Bill’s Blogs
  • Advertise
  • Subscribe

When reality intrudes on component models and equivalent circuits

March 12, 2023 By Bill Schweber Leave a Comment

Determining the utility of an equivalent-circuit model versus construction reality is often a difficult challenge.

Using simplified, first-order approximations in models and equivalent circuits is a normal part of engineering life. Without them, we would get mired in the details and harsh reality of the components and their characteristics. We would never be able to take those critical, rough-estimate first steps; instead, the well-known “paralysis by analysis” syndrome would take over.

This is especially the case for the complex equivalent circuits and their subtleties of RF designs — where the parasitics of just a few picofarads or nanohenries are critical — and in solid-state device physics, to cite two areas. But such fidelity concerns are for other disciplines as well, and it’s easy to get comfortable when looking at equations associated with these simplifications very easily.

Consider a simple wire loop: after all, there’s not much which is simpler than that. Its attributes adhere to Maxwell’s equations (perhaps better described as Oliver Heaviside’s reduction of Maxwell’s twenty-plus extremely complex equations to the four classic ones we know, but that’s another story; see “Twenty Three Years: The Acceptance of Maxwell’s Theory” and “Oliver Heaviside: A first-rate oddity“).

Nonetheless, even that simple wire loop — whether implemented in a basic paired-coil transformer, an RF inductor, or a toroidal transformer — has a reality that goes far beyond the first-order model commonly used to describe it.  Thus, deciding when the model is “good enough” for the application is often a difficult engineering decision.

One of the first things taught in basic EE class is the basic transformer-turns equations where the ratio of the number of primary turns N1 to the number of secondary turns N2 defines the step-up/step-down voltage and impedance ratio, (Figure 1). That simple equation makes for a good start at characterizing the transformer’s behavior and what it does for a circuit or power subsystem.

Transformer analysis
Fig 1: Transformer analysis invariably begins with a simple model and equivalent circuit. (Image: Quora)

Nonetheless, it’s naive to assume that all you need is N1/N2 for transformer design. This ratio serves as a vivid reminder that simplifications are good and necessary, but they are only starting-point approximations to a somewhat more-complete equivalent circuit (Figure 2).

enhanced model of a real transformer
Fig 2: The enhanced model of a real transformer brings in many more passive elements (Gc = conductance, Bm = susceptance) (Image: Custom Coils)

It would be great news if an equivalent-circuit model, even a complicated one, could fully capture the transformer’s reality with near-perfection. However, transformers also have challenging mechanical and insulation requirements to meet plus the vagaries of construction, which complicates their design idea versus as-built performance (Figure 3). These include winding issues due to wire gauge, insulation type and thickness, evenness and symmetry, thermal-induced changes, and more (see References 5 and 6).

Winding your own transformer
Fig 3: Winding your own transformer with little or no automated machinery shows the many subtleties and imperfections which affect final performance compared to the theoretical equivalent circuit and model. (Image: https://ludens.cl/Electron/Electron.html)

Achieving the high levels of performance often needed requires both a deep dive into the underlying equivalent-circuit model as well as the hands-on approach of build-evaluate-redo (and then repeat until satisfied). That’s where models fall short and designers must also rely on experience, rules of thumb, approximations, and estimates.

Equivalent-circuit models and hard-learned reality complement the other’s strengths and weaknesses. Of course, with the quality of many of today’s modeling tools and the powerful processors that execute them, the former approach is gaining more adherents:  it can save time and money, reduce frustration, and allow more “what-if” analysis of changes in parameters and their associated tradeoffs.

Calculating the specifics for a custom transformer, and then winding it yourself is an educational, satisfying, and frustrating experience, in varying proportions. One thing is sure: you’ll never say “no big deal…it’s ‘just’ a transformer” again.

External References

  1. “Build Your Own Transformer” – not sure why you would ever want to after reading this but you might have to, for a special application.
  2. “Analysis and Loss Mechanism of a Spiral Inductor Via the Green’s Function Model” – some truly serious math here.
  3. “Calculating the High-Frequency Resistance of Single and Double Layer Toroidal Windings” – also pretty deep stuff.
  4. “Designing a Discontinuous-Conduction-Mode Flyback Transformer” – in this power-supply topology, the transformer is the basic two-winding voltage transformer, and also an energy-storage inductor, with a more advanced model.
  5. “Transformers and coils” is an excellent introduction to the technology, art, and craft of DIY transformer winding and is a pre-cursor to the next item on this list.
  6. “Practical transformer winding” – a very serious and skilled amateur shows how he winds his own transformers; gives you a real sense and appreciation for what’s involved if you do it manually with various jigs and fixtures.

Related EE World Content

Transformers for ultrasonic sensing applications
Gate drive transformer specifications and applications
RF transformer specifications – Making the best of a non-ideal situation (Part 3)
Dealing with non-ideal transformers – Basic RF transformer theory of operation
What are the telegrapher’s equations?

 

You Might Also Like

Filed Under: Bill Schweber Blogs, Featured

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Primary Sidebar

EE Engineering Training Days

engineering

Featured Contributions

Integrating MEMS technology into next-gen vehicle safety features

Five challenges for developing next-generation ADAS and autonomous vehicles

Robust design for Variable Frequency Drives and starters

Meeting demand for hidden wearables via Schottky rectifiers

GaN reliability milestones break through the silicon ceiling

More Featured Contributions

EE Tech Toolbox

“ee
Tech Toolbox: 5G Technology
This Tech Toolbox covers the basics of 5G technology plus a story about how engineers designed and built a prototype DSL router mostly from old cellphone parts. Download this first 5G/wired/wireless communications Tech Toolbox to learn more!

EE Learning Center

EE Learning Center
“ee
EXPAND YOUR KNOWLEDGE AND STAY CONNECTED
Get the latest info on technologies, tools and strategies for EE professionals.
“bills
contribute

R&D World Podcasts

R&D 100 Episode 10
See More >

Sponsored Content

Designing for Serviceability: The Role of Interconnects in HVAC Maintenance

From Control Boards to Comfort: How Signal Integrity Drives HVAC Innovation

Built to Withstand: Sealing and Thermal Protection in HVAC Sub-Systems

Revolutionizing Manufacturing with Smart Factories

Smarter HVAC Starts at the Sub-System Level

Empowering aerospace E/E design and innovation through Siemens Xcelerator and Capital in the Cloud

More Sponsored Content >>

RSS Current EDABoard.com discussions

  • BA4116 reference resistance
  • unknown component z1
  • Collector Current Low side Has a large drop respect High Side during Miller during Double Pulse Test
  • is there vay for credit card size phone charger?
  • Question on options of set_clock_group

RSS Current Electro-Tech-Online.com Discussions

  • Fixing board, Easy question HEX SCHMITT
  • Can I make two inputs from one??
  • Display TFT ST7789 (OshonSoft Basic).
  • Home Smoke detectors are all Beeping Batteries are not dead.???
  • The Analog Gods Hate Me
Search Millions of Parts from Thousands of Suppliers.

Search Now!
design fast globle

Footer

EE World Online

EE WORLD ONLINE NETWORK

  • 5G Technology World
  • Analog IC Tips
  • Battery Power Tips
  • Connector Tips
  • DesignFast
  • EDABoard Forums
  • Electro-Tech-Online Forums
  • Engineer's Garage
  • EV Engineering
  • Microcontroller Tips
  • Power Electronic Tips
  • Sensor Tips
  • Test and Measurement Tips

EE WORLD ONLINE

  • Subscribe to our newsletter
  • Teardown Videos
  • Advertise with us
  • Contact us
  • About Us

Copyright © 2025 · WTWH Media LLC and its licensors. All rights reserved.
The material on this site may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used, except with the prior written permission of WTWH Media.

Privacy Policy